Shiri Appleby Expecting Second Child

Michael Kovac/Getty

It’s not unreal — Shiri Appleby is pregnant again!

The actress is expecting her second child with her fiancé, chef Jon Shook, she announced Monday on Twitter.

“…and then there were four,” Appleby — sporting quite the baby bump — captioned a photo of her family.

The star of Lifetime’s UnREAL and her beau, the co-owner of L.A. restaurants Animal, Son of a Gun and Trois Mec, are already parents to 2-year-old daughter Natalie Bouader.

“I’m having the time of my life. Being a mom has just really changed me and opened me up a lot,” Appleby told PEOPLE shortly after her daughter’s birth. “I’ve never been so happy and grateful for things.”

A few years in to raising her daughter, the actress found herself seeing her own childhood in a new light.

“What’s so exciting about being a mother is you look back on your own childhood in a totally different lens,” Appleby, 36, told PEOPLE in May.

“It really makes you appreciate the way you grew up and your parents in a way that you can’t really understand until you have a child of your own,” she added.

— Aili Nahas