Author: Manuel I Komnenos
Original Thread: Alexius Komnenos and the Byzantine-Pecheneg Wars

Alexius Komnenos and the Byzantine-Pecheneg Wars

  • The Pechenegs and the First Raids


Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
The Pechenegs had settled in the Ukrainian plains and the edges of the East Carpathian Mountains since the end of the 9th century AD. They were outstanding riders and archers and used masses of cavalry –mostly mounted archers- around a core of heavier armored cavalry (who were members of the aristocracy) as well as light infantry. Their nation consisted of 8 major hordes and 40 minor clans. Of the 8 major, the 3 noble ones were the Iabdiertim, the Kouartzitzur and the Chabouxingula (or Charoboi) while the rest 5 were the Katogyla, the Borotalmat, the Giazichopon, the Syroukalpei and the Boulatzopon.

Each horde could field 1.500 heavy armored cavalry and 10.000 light horse archers. If the numbers of infantry are added, we reach the conclusion that the Pechenegs were a particularly numerous nation. In periods of general mobilization they could easily mobilize more than 100.000 soldiers. In 1051 AD they were simultaneously involved in three fronts with 30.000 men against the Hungarians, 60.000 against Byzantium and 40.000 against Kiev.

As early as 950 AD, Emperor Constantine points out the unstable nature of the Pechenegs and that they were particularly aggressive and prone to looting. He suggests that the Byzantine diplomacy should concentrate in bribing the Pecheneg tribesmen and seeking the support of their Hungarian (“Turk”) neighbors.

During the 10th century AD, the Pechenegs were constantly transforming from friends of the Empire (during the expedition of John Jimiskes against the Rus in 971 AD) to enemies, allying themselves with the Rus in 941 and 969 or with the Bulgarians in 1016/17 and attacking the Byzantine lands along with their allies. For the first time, they attacked on behalf of themselves two years after the death of Basil II the Bulgar slayer in January of 1027 (something absolutely normal, as an attack against the Empire as long as he was alive would have been equivalent to suicide). Constantine, brother of Basil II was reigning and although he didn't have the abilities of his predecessor, he had a superb army at his disposal. For this reason, the attack was more of a reconnaissance than an actual raid. The Pechenegs captured some men whom they ransomed in 1030. In 1033, they crossed Danube starting a series of bloody raids which lasted with some breaks until 1122. Imperial forts were overrun, guards were slaughtered, villages were burned and large cities were besieged. The volume of loot and prisoners was increased in the successful raid of 1033 which was followed by another one in 1034. However, these can't be compared to the destructive raid of 1036, when the Pechenegs invaded Greece for 3 consecutive times. That horrible year, the Pecheneg hordes defeated the Imperial armies in a series of battles and captured a large number of prisoners and among them 5 generals.


  • 1046-1055 AD Constantine IX Monomachos and the Wars against the Pechenegs


Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
The sources are unclear as for what happened. The most probable thing is that they signed a Peace Treaty with the Empire because no further raids against Greek lands are mentioned, at least until 1046. That year, Kegen, a chieftain of this barbarian nation who had gained distinction in the Pechenegs’ wars with the Ouzes, decided to challenge Tyrach, the supreme Pecheneg chieftain for supreme command. In the ensuing battle, he was defeated and he as well as 20.000 of his compatriots crossed Danube and asked for asylum from Emperor Constantine IX Monomachos (1042-1055). The Imperial policy towards the Pecheneg chieftain was especially generous. He was baptized a Christian, given the title of Patricius and received 3 forts across Danube in Northern Bulgaria as well as supplies in order for him to be used as a first line defense against raids. However, Kegen was not restricted in defense. On the contrary, he started raiding areas north of the Danube River.

The rest of the Pecheneg chieftains were enraged by these actions and because they were suffering from a famine due to a harsh winter. On Christmas of 1046 and especially during the period from 15/12/1046 to 13/1/1047, crossed the freezing Danube and invaded in masses along with their families, slaves and property. Kedrenos speaks of 800.000 nomads and although these numbers seem exaggerated, they are probably not far from truth. At this critical moment, the Imperial Army acted instantly. Two armies, supported by the Pechenegs of Kegen, attacked from two sides and annihilated them. Their remnants were resettled by the Emperor in depopulated areas of the Bulgarian and Paristrion Themes.

In the middle of 1048 AD and under continuous pressure from the Seljuks in the Eastern borders, Emperor Constantine ordered the general mobilization of the Eastern Themes. He also sent aid from the Western Themes as well as 15.000 Pechenegs. However, the Pechenegs were not so cooperative with the Byzantines and before crossing Bosporus, they murdered the Imperial delegates and returned to Central Bulgaria. They even brought more of their compatriots from the areas north of the Danube and begun their raids once again. Magister Constantine Arianetes marched against them. The latter met with the enemy in June of 1049 somewhere in Northern Thrace. In the following battle, the Imperial army was defeated, losing 3.000 men and 2 generals. In a second engagement, the Byzantines were defeated once again.

The Emperor understood that the situation was worse than he thought and that he needed larger forces in order to face the Pechenegs. Therefore, he recalled 20.000 men from Pontus and forces from Western Asia Minor and in the fall of 1050, he had amassed 50.000 soldiers in Adrianople. Under the command of Nikephorus, an eunuch, the Imperial Army met in battle with the enemy on the 8th of June, 1050. The Imperial Army was slaughtered. Ignoring the recommendations of his generals who were telling him to wait for the enemy in their entrenched camp, Nikephoros attacked. The soldiers marched through vineyard fields and fences, losing their cohesion and getting slaughtered in the process. The dead were more than 18.000, while the wounded and captured were decapitated by the barbarian nomads. An incident, points out the hate between the two enemies. The Vestarches Michael Dokianos was brought as a prisoner to a Pecheneg chieftain. He suddenly grabbed a hidden small sword and pinned it to the Pecheneg’s neck, shouting “I don’t fear of becoming a killer of an enemy”. The Pechenegs who were around slaughtered him.
The Pecheneg raids continued in the next years. The region of Thrace suffered heavily. During 1052, their vanguard reached Central Macedonia and Thessalonica was threatened. In 1053, the Imperial armies suffered one more defeat when they were attacked by Pecheneg forces while besieging the Bulgarian capital. In 1054, Pecheneg hordes invaded Thrace while at the same time the Imperial forces were trying to defend against the Seljuks of Togrul Bay in the city of Matzikert and against the Normans in Italy.


  • 1055-1066 AD Isaac Komnenos, Romanus Diogenes and the Wars against the Pechenegs


Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
The Imperial Army started to prevail under the guidance of the new domestichus of the Scolae of the East, Isaac Komnenos (1007-1060), uncle of later Emperor Alexius Komnenos. Isaac landed on Thrace along with veteran Asia Minor soldiers, united with the forces of Nikephoros Bryennius, domestichus of the Scolae of the West and by winning a series of victories against the Pecheneges, he limited them in Central Bulgaria. In 1055, a 30 year Peace Treaty was signed but it didn’t last for long. In 1059, the Pechenegs violated the Treaty and again started the raids and slaughters. Isaac I Komnenos, now an Emperor (1057-1059), in head of 60.000 men, moved through the snowy mountains and hit the nomads hard, achieving a big victory. However, the Pechenegs, exploiting the continuous pressure of the Seljuks in the East, conducted new raids in 1061, 1063 and 1064.

In 1066 AD and according to Michael Attaliates, Romanus Diogenes, the Duke of Serdica and later Emperor (1068-1071) achieved a great victory against the Pechenegs capturing many of them alive and sending the heads of the slain off to emperor Constantine Ducas who gave him the honor of vestarch. The catastrophe must have been huge for the Pechenegs, given that they didn't conduct any raids for the next 10 years. Many Pechenegs joined the Imperial Army and fought in Matzikert five years later.


  • 1084-1090 AD Alexius Komnenos Pt I – The constant turns of the tides of war


Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
The following years were tragic for Byzantium. Especially the decade of 1070-1080 is probably one of the worst in the history of Hellenism. The defeat at Mazikert was followed by a general invasion of the Seljuks and Turcomans in Asia Minor, while the Normans, having consolidated their gains in Southern Italy landed in Dyrrhachium (Durazzo). During the reign of Nikephorus III Botaneiates (1078-1081), the Pechenegs invaded Thrace and besieged Adrianople where the rebel Nikephorus Bryennios had found refuge. They left after receiving a large amount of money. At the same period, a young general, Alexius Komnenos who served the Empire managed to neutralize two claimants to the throne, Nikephorus Bryennius and Nikephorus Basilakes, and ascend to the throne after removing old Nikephorus Botaneiates. The situation he was facing was chaotic. Immediately after his ascension, he had had to face a 3-front war in the East, North and West.

Exploiting the Norman and Seljuk invasions, the Pechegs raided Thrace, facing weak Imperial forces. In 1084, they besieged Durostolon. During the same period, the war against the Normans had reached its peak and Alexius was unable to allocate more men against the Pechenegs.

In the spring of 1086, 50.000 nomads invaded the Imperial territory once again. Gregorius Pacurianos, domesticus of the West and general Nikolaos Branas were sent along with 17.000 men to deal with them. The invaders outnumbered the Byzantines to 3:1 ratio. Pacurianos suggested that they should wait for reinforcements but Branas insisted that they should attack saying he and his men were ready to fight. Finally, the opinion of the latter prevailed and the army was ordered to attack. The soldiers from Asia Minor, Thessaly and Macedonia as well as a unit of Frankish troops left the camp shouting, took battle formation and immediately attacked the Pechenegs who had already begun to flood the hills. The Byzantines hadn't moved for more than a few hundred meters when they were suddenly flanked by thousands of light cavalry while at the same time the center of the Imperial formation was suffering an attack by the Pecheneg heavy cavalry. The Byzantine Army was unable to withstand the pressure of the attack and therefore lost its cohesion, broke its formation and was initially slaughtered. Pacurianos, wounded in his arm continued to fight. But his horse was killed and while falling he broke his neck. A few meters closer, Branas was falling, hit by uncountable arrows.

The news of the disaster struck Alexius like a lightning bolt, while he was camped outside of Didymoteicho. However, the Emperor was not a man who'd easily lose hope and despair. He immediately called for the domesticus of the East, Taticius, who was still fighting against the Turks, to cross the Hellespont with as many men as he could and meet him in Adrianople. There, he handed him 8.000 Greek soldiers and a body of 1.500 Latin mercenaries from Cyzicus, under Umvertopoulos. Taticius, in head of 25.000 soldiers moved north, towards Phillipopolis.

The scouts found a large force of Pechenegs which was returning back, full with loot and prisoners. The Imperial Army struck the unsuspecting nomads. They were scattered leaving back their loot, prisoners and 4.000 dead. Taticius tried to persecute them in order to defeat them completely but the attempt failed because it was too dangerous for the Imperial Army to march through the mountainous area of Bulgaria. So, he returned to Constantinople (October 1086). This victory was mostly a tactic one and not a strategic one because the Pechenegs returned the next year.

In April of 1087, 80.000 of them along with Ogguzes and Hungarians invaded Thrace and camped in the area of Scoteinon, near river Ebrus. The generals Nicolaos Maurokatakalon and John Vempetziotes marched against them with 25.000 soldiers. The two generals moved towards the Pamfilon fort between Didimoteicho and Rhaidestus, in order to organize their defense there. But the Imperial roads were full of civilians who were trying to find refuge from the Pechenegs.
They had been identified by Pecheneg scouts and it was sure that the next day they'd have to face the enemy. When it dawned, general Maurokatakalon went to a hill near the plains of Dydimoteicho along with his staff and witnessed the dust overwhelming the plains because of the thousand horses of the Pechenegs as they were arriving to battle the Byzantines. The general was shocked. His officers though, insisted that he should attack the nomads immediately.

Maurokatakalon and Vempetziotes divided their army in 3 parts and moved quickly, surprising the enemy. In the intense fighting that followed, the tides of battle steadily turned towards the Pechenegs until their general Gelgu suffered a deadly hit. In the meantime, the Hungarian Solomon suffered an arrow hit in his eye. The nomads panicked and they started retreating. The Pechenegs left 9.000 dead in the field of battle.

Despite their defeat, the Pechenegs continued their raids. The Emperor was losing his patience. The wars against them had cost the Empire a great amount of money and manpower. Thousands of civilians were killed while huge areas of Macedonia, Thrace and Bulgaria had been destroyed. All the attempts of Alexius to come in terms or divide the Pecheneg chieftains had failed. He realized that arms would give the final solution. Therefore, he personally led a new campaign against them. In the 10th of May, 1087 he left Constantinople, in head of some 2/3 of the Imperial Tagmata (3.000 Immortals, 800 Vestiaritai, 2.000 Archontopouloi, and 700 Chomatinians) and marched towards Adrianople. In his way towards the city, he added more units in his army, raising his numerical strength.

In Adrianople, Alexius was united with the forces of Katakalon and Vempetziotes. Adrianos Komnenos, the new domesticus of the West, joined them up with the “Latinikon”, a unit of 6.000 French, Italian and Norman mercenaries. Alexius marched towards the North reaching an area called Lardaea (Central Bulgaria). In the meantime, the Imperial fleet was ordered to move in Danube in the area of Dorystolon in order to cut the retreat of the nomads.

The Emperor stayed in Lardaea for 40 days, waiting for more reinforcements. His objective was now to hit the Pechenegs hard and annihilate them and not just to intercept their raids. In the war council, he expressed his intension to hit the nomads in Northern Bulgaria. His older generals, Nikephorus Bryennios and Gregorius Maurokatakalon objected this idea while his younger ones, George Palaiologos, Nikephorus Mellisinus and the two sons of former Emperor Romanus IV Diogenes, Nikephorus and Leon (18 and 16 years old respectively), said that they were ready to attack and slaughter the enemy. Alexius, carried away by the optimistic comments of his young generals raised his sword and shouted “The Pechenegs only understand the language of steel!” Hence, a large force of 54.000 men marched in formation, moved through the mountainous area of Bulgaria and was again united in Dorystolon. There, a force of 70.000 Pechenegs was awaiting them ready for battle. Alexius ordered 5 men to guard him. These were the two sons of Romanus IV, Nikolaos Maurokatakalon, Ioannakes the captain of the Varangian Guard and Gules, a friend of his.

The blooded battle lasted until late at night and the casualties were huge for both sides. After the first clashes, the Pechenegs were fortified behind their wagons placed in a circle and defended from there. Alexius was trying to break their defense with continuous assaults. However, the Pechenegs were fighting fiercely and were counterattacking. The battle was undecided until sunset when suddenly, 36.000 Pechenegs appeared moving towards the battlefield. The morale of the Imperial Army was broken and it retreated in complete disorder. The Emperor, with his sword in his hand continued to fight heroically. Finally, he understood that the cause was lost and decided to retreat with the soldiers that remained near him.

The Roman casualties amounted to 11.000 dead and 6.000 captured men. The Pechenegs had 9.500 dead. In this battle Alexius suffered a light hit by a spear. Even though he wasn't wounded, a continuous pain was troubling him for years. The Emperor gathered the remnants of his army, purchased the prisoners by handing large amounts of money to the Pechenegs and started recruiting additional men. Phillipopolis though had been already conquered by the nomads (August of 1088). Alexius tried to limit the Pecheneg raids with guerrilla tactics, small raids and small-scale attacks in order to gather soldiers from Asia Minor. However, the situation was tragic there as well (1088-Autumn of 1089). The heavy winter of 1089-1090 helped the Byzantines as the Pechenegs stopped their raids. However, in the spring of 1090, they returned and captured Chariopolis. In the June of 1090, the Imperial Army was once again defeated. The worst thing was that the elite Archontopouloi Tagma (sons of dead officers) was almost annihilated, losing some 300 men. This saddened the Emperor.

The Byzantines answered later. A unit of 1.000 Pechenegs was ambushed and annihilated by Taticius. In December of 1090, the Pechenegs moved towards Eastern Thrace, near Marmara. Alexius was waiting for them though, and a large battle was fought between them, although it was undecided. Alexius retreated 30 km west of Constantinople, where he reorganized his forces. A new battle was fought the next day. This time the Pechenegs were defeated, suffering 7.000 casualties.

Then, the Emperor rested his army for 3 days and left for Jurulo where he camped in a castle. The Pechenegs followed him and camped in the plains, between the castle and a river. There, Alexius, seeing that his forces were not sufficient for a hand to hand battle, thought about a trick. During the night, he hanged some wheels by ropes in the walls. In the morning, the Imperial Army marched against the Pechenegs. The Pechenegs attacked the Byzantines who retreated with order, just as their plans were. Suddenly, the trumpets rang and the Byzantine Army was divided in 2 units, leaving enough space between them. That moment, the soldiers cut the ropes and the wheels started rolling down, killing all the Pechenegs in front of them. At the same time, the soldiers were slaughtering those who had fallen from their horses. The rest of them retreated.

Despite their loss, the Pechenegs were again ready for battle the very next day. This time, the Imperial Army, with its morale in its peak, came out of the castle and attacked the nomads. The Byzantine victory was overwhelming.

The winter had finally come. Alexius decided to return to Constantinople letting his army rest. He placed Ioannakes and Nikolaos Maurokatakalon as generals with the objective to keep the Pechenegs in check and recruit more men. It was obvious that with the arrival of spring, a deciding battle was about to occur.


  • 1091 AD Alexius Komnenos Pt II – The decisive victory and the end of the Pecheneg Wars


Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
The public opinion had put pressure on Alexius for results and it was obvious that a bloody battle was underway. Senators, officers, soldiers, the clergy and the citizens were determined to end their business with the Pechenegs once and for all. The Seljuk pressure in Asia Minor was already strong and had to be given there.

Alexius undertook huge armaments. After recruiting Thracians, Macedonians, garrisons from Central Greece, Peloponnese and the islands of Northern Aegean, Latin mercenaries and 500 men from Flanders, combined with the Imperial Tagmata and the Varangian Guard (some 50.000 men), he left the city in April of 1091 and marched towards inner Thrace. He managed to sign a last minute alliance with the Cumans. He promised the Cuman leaders that he’d let them take all the spoils of war for themselves while he didn’t desire anything. The Cumans agreed and swore their allegiance.

The Army remained camp for some time and then left in order to capture a pass near the river Filocalus. In its way the army met a Pecheneg force and clashed with them. The Imperial forces prevailed but they didn't stay there for long. They headed towards an area called Levounion, a hill that stands in the middle of the homonymous plains. In the Tuesday 29th of April of 1091, after an all-night prayer, the army exited the camp and prepared a huge battle formation of 95.000 men. Against him, he had the entire Pecheneg force, 110.000 men, together with their wives and children, behind a huge circle of wagons which they used as walls. Alexius praised his soldiers and called for the attack, The battle formation, looking as a half-moon, fell upon the Pechenegs with tremendous force and intensity. The Pecheneg lines were broken in a few minutes and a huge slaughter begun. The Emperor himself was fighting heroically upon his horse.

Until nightfall, a whole nation had been exterminated. 60.000 Pechenegs lay dead, on the Thracian plains. The casualties of the Byzantine army amounted to 12.000 men while those of the Cumans were some 6.500. The captured men, women and children amounted to 50.000. They were slaughtered the very same night, probably following an order from the Emperor. This was the bloodiest battle of the 11th Century AD, and one of the bloodiest of the Medieval era.


  • Conclusion


Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
The Pecheneg problem started as a small nuisance and progressed to a grave danger for the very existence of Byzantium. It is estimated that the Pecheneg Wars cost the Empire more than 80.000 men who'd have proved useful against the Seljuks. The civilian casualties among the Greek populations of Macedonia and Thrace are unknown. The destruction of property, agriculture and livestock is unimaginable given that the countryside was completely desolated.

The Empire was so lucky as to have a great Emperor such as Alexius Komnenos, a charismatic politician and military mastermind, admirer of diplomacy as well as military affairs. Crucial, friendly with his friends but relentless with his enemies, the Emperor managed to withstand the difficulties he faced. He left a strong Empire and a well-trained and prepared army to his successor. He stands in the Pantheon of the Byzantine Emperors, along with Basil II and Heraclius.


Bibliography
Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

1) Anna Komnena - The Alexiad
2) Nikephoros Bryennios the Younger - Materials for a History
3) John Skylitzes: A Synopsis of Byzantine History, 811-1057
4) George Kedrenos - Compendium Historiarum
5) Constantine VII Porphyrogenitus - De Administrando Imperio
6) Michael Attaleiates - Michaelis Attaliotae Historia
7) Constantine Paparrigopoulos - History of the Hellenic nation
8) Michael Angold - The Byzantine Empire, 1025-1204
9) Paul Stephenson - Byzantium's Balkan Frontier
10) G.Ostrogorsky - History of the Byzantine State
11) Ian Heath - Armies of the Dark Ages 600-1066
12) John Julius Norwich - Byzantium, The Decline and Fall
13) A.A. Vasiliev - History of the Byzantine empire