Summer without sauce? Saying 'I don't' Tracking inflation Best CD rates this month
PROBLEM SOLVED
Halloween

The perfect Halloween pumpkin? Here's how to choose the right jack-o-lantern for carving

Maryal Miller Carter
USA TODAY

When trying to pick the perfect pumpkin, ever find yourself overwhelmed by the vast array of choices at the pumpkin patch?

We get it! With a multitude of shapes, colors and sizes, choosing the ideal canvas for your carving talents can be confounding.

But did you know that there's actually a science to the pumpkin-picking process?

You might think you're just picking a good-looking gourd, but everything from sturdy walls to healthy stems and even the sound your pumpkin makes can impact its longevity and suitability for carving.

So hold on to your witch's hat because we're unveiling all the secrets you need to know when selecting the ideal pumpkin for carving this Halloween.

Watch the video above to learn how to choose the perfect pumpkin for carving.

Halloween Pumpkin Carving:Preserving

How to choose a pumpkin for carving

  • For carving, opt for pumpkins with smooth, even skin and consistent coloring for a clean canvas.
  • Prioritize pumpkins free of soft spots and deep scratches by thoroughly examining their skin.
  • Ensure a longer-lasting pick by choosing pumpkins with firm, non-mushy bottoms and sturdy stems. Weak stems indicate a less durable choice.
  • Safeguard the stem by carrying your pumpkin from the sides or underneath.
  • Test for thin skin by tapping the pumpkin; a hollow sound is ideal for easier carving.
  • Select pie pumpkins for culinary ventures, as they boast solid interiors unsuitable for carving.
  • Explore heirloom pumpkins, prized for their unique shapes, distinctive colors and imperfect skins. These are perfect for creative Halloween and Fall decor.
  • Opt for locally grown pumpkins to enjoy the freshest, long-lasting options.
  • Embrace imperfections and quirks in your pumpkin choices to infuse character into a playful Halloween display.

Make your house smell like fall: How to make a pumpkin spice oil diffuser

Tips to make Halloween pumpkins last longer

  • Before you carve, wash the outside of your pumpkin with soap and water to eliminate dirt and mold spores, promoting a longer lifespan.
  • Place your pumpkin in a cool, shaded area while on display. Direct sunlight and heat can expedite deterioration.
  • Apply petroleum jelly inside and on carved edges after carving. This forms a protective barrier, retaining the pumpkin's firmness and moisture. CAUTION: Never use real flames with petroleum jelly; opt for battery-powered lights instead.

Reviewed-approved kitchen and cooking recommendations 

Purchases you make through our links may earn us and our publishing partners a commission.  

Reviewed helps you find the best stuff and get the most out of what you already own. Our team of kitchen and cooking experts are always testing new kitchen tools, appliances and more so you can shop for the best of the best.  

Featured Weekly Ad